Improving Donor Acquisition with Programmatic Ads

Nonprofits often struggle to find new donors efficiently, especially with limited budgets and resources. Programmatic advertising offers a data-driven solution, automating ad placements to reach the right audience at the right time. This approach reduces wasted spending and maximizes impact by targeting individuals based on their interests, behaviors, and demographics. Here's how programmatic ads can help nonprofits:

• Precision Targeting: Use donor data and third-party insights to reach potential supporters with tailored messages.
• Cost-Effectiveness: Focus ad spend on high-intent audiences, optimizing for metrics like cost per new donor (CPND) and return on ad spend (ROAS).
• Scalability: Extend reach across platforms like display ads, video, and connected TV without significantly increasing workload.
• Measurable Impact: Track metrics like conversion rates and donor retention to refine campaigns and improve results.

For example, Georgia Mountain Food Bank achieved a 200% ROAS and raised over $36,500 through targeted digital campaigns. By setting clear goals, testing ad formats, and refining donation pages, your nonprofit can attract more donors and boost contributions effectively.

Getting Started With Digital Ads

Setting Goals, Budgets, and Success Metrics

Getting programmatic advertising right starts with defining clear, actionable goals that connect your fundraising vision to measurable digital outcomes. Whether you're aiming for more donors, higher donation amounts, or a boost in monthly contributions, you need to establish these targets before launching any campaign. From there, align these goals with specific digital benchmarks to keep your efforts focused and effective.

Connecting Fundraising Goals to Digital Targets

Your fundraising goals should translate directly into trackable digital metrics. Break your broader objectives into quarterly targets that can be monitored and adjusted as needed. For instance, RKD Group partnered with American Bible Society to align their programmatic campaigns with their direct mail donor demographics. By running display ads and paid search campaigns year-round, they built awareness and maintained steady donor acquisition.

Consider where potential donors are in their journey with your organization. For awareness campaigns, focus on metrics like impressions and reach. For conversion campaigns, track donations and cost per new donor. If your goal is to increase recurring donations, segment your audience to target monthly givers versus one-time donors. Tailor your messaging accordingly and measure success using metrics like lifetime value per acquisition and post-campaign retention rates.

Planning Your Campaign Budget

Effective budget planning is both realistic and adaptable. Start with a $5,000–$10,000 test budget over 4–6 weeks, distributing funds as follows: 40% to display ads, 30% to video, and 30% to connected TV. This approach provides enough data to evaluate performance without overextending your resources.

For U.S. nonprofits, digital donor acquisition should be a year-round focus, but it's wise to allocate extra resources during peak giving seasons. Devote 50–70% of your seasonal budget to November and December, when donor intent tends to be highest. For example, campaigns timed to these months have shown returns like a 200% ROAS. Once your budget is set, shift your attention to tracking the metrics that will confirm your campaign’s success.

Measuring Key Performance Indicators

To gauge the effectiveness of your campaigns, focus on three key metrics: cost per new donor (CPND), return on ad spend (ROAS), and conversion rate.

• CPND: Divide your total ad spend by the number of new donors acquired. Aim for a range of $20–$50, depending on your cause and donor lifetime value.
• ROAS: This measures revenue generated per dollar spent. For example, a 200% ROAS means you earned $2 for every $1 invested in ads.
• Conversion Rate: Calculate this by dividing donations by clicks or impressions. For programmatic display and video campaigns targeting new donors, expect conversion rates between 0.5–2%.

Keep your team focused by prioritizing one primary KPI and 2–3 supporting metrics, such as click-through rates or email sign-ups. This ensures attention stays on the most meaningful indicators of success.

Building and Targeting the Right Audiences

Reaching the right supporters for your cause begins with tapping into your donor data and enhancing it with broader third-party insights. Your donor database is a goldmine of information - think age groups, locations, donation history, and engagement patterns. Use this data to create audience personas and then enrich them with third-party data from platforms like The Trade Desk or Google DV360. This combination allows you to connect your mission with potential donors more effectively.

Using Your Data and External Segments

To start, dig into your existing donor base to uncover shared traits. Look at demographics like age and income, patterns in donation timing, and past campaign behaviors to identify what first-time donors have in common. Next, upload this segmented data to your platform and enhance it with third-party segments. These might include categories like "charitable donors", "environmental charity donors", or interests that align with your cause.

For example, American Bible Society expanded their donor base by analyzing the demographics and giving patterns from their direct mail lists. They then applied these insights to digital channels, running year-round programmatic campaigns targeting similar profiles across various formats. By blending first-party data with trusted third-party segments, you can broaden your reach without compromising donor quality.

Targeting Methods to Attract New Donors

Demographic targeting zeroes in on age, income levels, and household characteristics that align with your most engaged donors. Location-based targeting focuses your efforts on specific states, cities, or ZIP codes where you operate or see high donation activity. You can also use geo-fencing to target areas around events, partner locations, or places tied to your mission.

Interest-based targeting is another effective strategy, reaching individuals who are interested in topics like disaster relief, education, veterans support, or animal welfare. Additionally, you can target related lifestyle interests to connect with people who resonate with your cause. Behavioral targeting identifies users who have previously donated, visited charity websites, or engaged with similar organizations.

Privacy and Data Protection Guidelines

Once you've defined your targeting strategies, it's essential to prioritize donor trust by implementing strong data protection practices. Ensure your privacy policy clearly explains how you collect, use, and share data for marketing purposes, including cookies and advertising IDs. Offer simple opt-out options for email, SMS, and advertising cookies, and act quickly to honor user preferences.

For California residents, adhere to the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), which grants users the right to opt out of data sales. Avoid using sensitive data like health or religious information, and only work with platforms and data providers that strictly follow privacy regulations. When uploading donor lists, use anonymized or hashed data, and conduct regular audits to ensure your targeting practices remain secure and transparent.

Creating Effective Ads and Donation Pages

To turn interest into action, you need ads and donation pages that are engaging and simple to navigate. Building on earlier campaign strategies, this section dives into crafting ads and donation pages that drive results.

Ad Formats and Messaging That Resonate with Donors

Different ad formats serve different purposes. Display ads are great for raising awareness and retargeting audiences at a low cost, helping you reach new people on a large scale. Video ads, whether online or on Connected TV (CTV), excel at sharing emotional stories that quickly build trust and inspire action, making them perfect for converting donors. Native ads, which blend seamlessly with the content around them, often see higher engagement rates. They’re especially effective for driving traffic to detailed stories or donation pages without disrupting the user experience.

When creating ad messages, focus on three key elements: a clear problem, a specific solution, and a tangible impact. For example, "Your $50 provides 100 meals" makes the donor’s contribution feel real and actionable. Stories centered on individuals, families, or communities help donors connect emotionally with your cause. Use direct calls-to-action like "Donate Now" and include concise social proof to emphasize urgency. Keep the language simple and easy to read, especially since many donors will view these ads on small mobile screens.

Leverage programmatic platforms to tailor ads for different audiences. For example, show family-oriented visuals and education-focused messages to parents, while using nature imagery and climate-related language for environmentally conscious supporters. Also, adapt your creative approach based on device type: on mobile, shorter text, bold visuals, and vertical videos work best; on desktop, longer explanations and horizontal videos can be more effective.

Designing Donation Pages That Drive Action

Your donation page should be simple and focused. Use a clear headline that highlights impact, one prominent donation form, and minimal navigation to keep users on task. Since many donors use smartphones, ensure the page is mobile-friendly with large buttons, readable fonts, and forms optimized for touch screens.

Only ask for essential information - name, email, and payment details - to reduce friction. Offer preset donation amounts like $25, $50, $100, and $250, along with a custom option, and clearly distinguish between one-time and monthly giving in U.S. dollars. Features like progress indicators, inline error messages, and clear confirmation pages can further streamline the process. Fast-loading pages are critical, especially for donors using mobile networks.

Build trust by prominently displaying security and privacy indicators, like SSL certificates (https and lock icons) and payment logos (Visa, Mastercard, PayPal). Add third-party validations like Charity Navigator or BBB Wise Giving Alliance badges, and transparency statements like "85% of every dollar goes to programs". Testimonials, brief impact stories, and phrases like "Join 5,000 supporters this year" can boost donor confidence. Including contact information and a simple FAQ about how donations are used reassures donors of your credibility.

To encourage larger gifts and recurring donations, present suggested amounts in ascending order, calibrated to typical donor capacities. For instance, $25–$250 for one-time gifts and $10–$100 for monthly contributions are common ranges for U.S. nonprofits. Connect each amount to a specific outcome, such as "$25 feeds one family for a week", to motivate donors to give more. Highlight the monthly giving option by pre-selecting it with a modest default amount, and explain its importance with statements like "Monthly gifts help us plan ahead and respond faster in emergencies".

Refining Ads and Donation Pages Through Testing

Once your ads and donation pages are live, refine them through testing. Experiment with headlines (e.g., "Feed a child for $1/day" vs. "Children are going hungry tonight"), imagery (close-up human faces vs. abstract designs), and calls-to-action ("Donate now" vs. "See how you can help"). Compare static images with short videos, or test different storytelling angles, like an individual’s story versus a broader community impact. Focus on one variable at a time to clearly identify what works best, and then allocate your budget to the top-performing versions.

For donation pages, use testing tools available in many fundraising platforms to create different versions and split traffic between them. Priority tests could include shorter versus longer forms, different headlines and impact statements, and variations in the placement of recurring-gift options. Keep the user experience consistent by using the same confirmation page and receipt. Avoid aggressive pop-ups that might interrupt the donation process. Track metrics like conversion rates, average gift size, and completion times over two to four weeks to determine which version performs better and make it your new default.

For nonprofits with annual revenues between $1–$20 million, partnering with specialized agencies can be a game-changer. These partners, like Share Services, bring expertise in digital fundraising, donor retention, and new donor acquisition. They handle programmatic campaigns, A/B testing, and performance analysis, freeing your team to focus on your mission while benefiting from professional-level digital advertising and optimization tailored to U.S. nonprofits.

sbb-itb-deea482

Launching and Growing Your Campaigns

To run effective campaigns, focus on testing, refining, and scaling your efforts systematically. This approach helps you attract more donors while keeping your budget and return on investment in check.

Starting with a Test Campaign

Begin with a 4–6 week test campaign, allocating a total budget of $3,000–$10,000 and capping daily spending at $100–$300. Set a single, clear goal - like acquiring 100 new donors at a cost of $40 or less per donor. Stick to 1–2 programmatic channels, such as display ads and Connected TV, to keep things manageable. Make sure to set up conversion tracking on your donation page from the outset. Create 3–5 ad variations to test different messaging approaches, and schedule your campaign with specific start and end dates in your local time zone (e.g., Eastern Time). This focused testing phase allows you to validate your strategy before committing to a larger budget. Once the initial data is in, you can shift toward improving and expanding your efforts.

Improving Campaign Performance

As your test campaign runs, focus on making steady, data-driven adjustments instead of reacting to daily ups and downs. In the first week, double-check that tracking is accurate, spending aligns with your plan, and there are no technical issues with your ads or donation pages. From weeks 2 to 4, start optimizing by increasing budgets or bids on well-performing placements and audience segments by 10–20% increments. At the same time, reduce spending on low-performing areas and fine-tune targeting by excluding underperforming sites or narrowing geographic focus.

If you're seeing plenty of clicks but not enough conversions, review your donation page for potential improvements. Check for faster load times, clear messaging, mobile-friendly design, and alignment with your ad content. On the other hand, if conversions are strong but impressions are limited, consider slightly raising your bids, broadening your audience while keeping it relevant, or adding formats like native ads or online video. Rotate your creative elements by pausing ads that aren't performing well and testing new ones. Make small adjustments and give them a few days to show meaningful trends.

Expanding Successful Campaigns

Once your campaign consistently hits its performance targets, it's time to scale. Use the insights gained from testing and optimization to expand your reach. If you're meeting or exceeding your cost-per-acquisition (CPA) and return-on-ad-spend (ROAS) goals for several weeks, increase your daily budgets by 15–30% to grow your audience efficiently. Broaden your geographic targeting to include new high-potential areas within the U.S., or add complementary channels like Connected TV, online video, or native ads to engage similar audiences in different ways.

You can also build lookalike audiences based on your newly acquired donors to reach others who share similar traits. Set strict limits on your maximum CPA or minimum ROAS to maintain quality as you scale. For example, focusing on high-intent audiences through programmatic campaigns can effectively grow your donor base while keeping costs under control.

To integrate these efforts into a larger donor-acquisition strategy, enroll new donors in an email welcome series, invite them to events, and coordinate direct-mail outreach with consistent branding across all platforms. Keep tracking long-term metrics like second-gift conversion rates, 12-month donor retention, and lifetime value for donor groups. These insights will help you measure the broader impact of your campaigns over time.

How Share Services Can Support Your Campaigns

For mid-sized nonprofits with annual revenues between $1–$20 million, programmatic advertising can be a game-changer. But many organizations in this range lack the in-house expertise to fully leverage it. That’s where Share Services steps in, offering tailored support for digital fundraising, donor acquisition, and targeted digital advertising.

Share Services takes care of every stage of your campaign. A dedicated nonprofit strategist works closely with your team to translate your fundraising goals into clear, measurable KPIs - like cost per new donor or return on ad spend. From there, they design programmatic campaigns that focus on building detailed donor personas and crafting messaging that resonates with both new and returning supporters. This end-to-end approach ensures your campaigns stay aligned with your donor acquisition objectives.

But it doesn’t stop at setup. Share Services continuously optimizes your campaigns through A/B testing of ad creatives, fine-tuning mobile donation pages for better performance, and using remarketing strategies to re-engage visitors. Their paid media services, starting at $1,500 per month, include platforms like Meta Ads, OTT Ads, and Direct Deal Ads, along with detailed analytics and donor acquisition support. For nonprofits looking for more comprehensive guidance, a $3,500 monthly strategy retainer covers weekly strategy sessions, project management, and KPI reporting.

Paid Media Specialist Eddie Laing underscores the importance of a multi-channel approach:

"It costs less to reactivate a lapsed donor than to acquire a new one. Email can be effective, but multi-channel approaches are even better. We did this with Focus and saw great results for them."

Conclusion

Programmatic advertising streamlines digital outreach by targeting individuals already interested in your cause. Take the Georgia Mountain Food Bank as an example - they achieved a 200% return on ad spend and raised over $36,500 in donations through focused digital campaigns.

To replicate this kind of success, you need a clear strategy and a commitment to ongoing refinement. Start by setting specific goals and aligning them with measurable metrics like cost per new donor or return on ad spend (ROAS). Use your existing donor data to create audiences and lookalike segments that reflect your most engaged supporters. Launch a test campaign, track its performance, and adjust based on the results you see.

Remarketing and consistent optimization play a big role here. Experiment with different ad messages, fine-tune your donation pages, and allocate more budget to the strategies that deliver the best outcomes. Programmatic advertising supports every step of the donor journey - from raising awareness to encouraging repeat contributions - making it a reliable tool for building a strong supporter base year-round. By constantly refining your approach, you can ensure your donor acquisition strategy stays effective and adaptable.

For mid-sized nonprofits, working with experts like Share Services can help transform your digital ad spend into meaningful, long-term donor relationships. With the right strategy, combined with regular testing and improvement, programmatic advertising becomes a dependable way to attract new supporters and advance your mission.

FAQs

How do programmatic ads help nonprofits attract new donors?

Programmatic ads offer nonprofits a powerful way to connect with potential donors by leveraging advanced targeting techniques. These tools help ensure your message reaches the right audience - those most likely to resonate with and support your cause - at the perfect moment, boosting both visibility and engagement.

What’s more, programmatic advertising makes it possible to retarget individuals who’ve already expressed interest in your organization. This increases the likelihood of turning that interest into meaningful donations. By making the most of your ad spend, programmatic ads allow nonprofits to achieve strong results without overspending, providing an efficient way to grow donor support.

What metrics should nonprofits track to measure the success of programmatic ad campaigns?

To gauge how well programmatic ad campaigns are performing, nonprofits should pay close attention to metrics like cost per acquisition (CPA), click-through rate (CTR), and conversion rate. These indicators reveal how effectively your ads are driving actions like engagement and donations.

It's also important to monitor return on ad spend (ROAS) and donor retention rate to understand the broader impact and long-term viability of your efforts. Metrics such as impressions and ad frequency can further fine-tune your targeting approach, helping ensure your message connects with the right audience.

How can nonprofits protect supporter data when using programmatic advertising?

Nonprofits can safeguard supporter data by adopting transparent data privacy policies and utilizing reliable, secure data management systems. It's crucial to obtain explicit consent from supporters before collecting or using their information and to adhere to privacy regulations like GDPR or CCPA.

To maintain high standards, regularly audit and review your data practices, limit access to sensitive information to only authorized team members, and stay informed about evolving data protection strategies. These measures not only protect supporter information but also help maintain their trust while effectively using programmatic advertising.

Related Blog Posts

• Creating Effective Online Fundraising Campaigns: A Guide
• How Donor Data Improves Ad Targeting
• Case Study: Faith-Based Ad Campaigns That Worked
• Case Study: Facebook Ads for Church Fundraising Success